fedi meta 

Something fedi gets very wrong is that it tries so hard to basically be Twitter but decentralised, but it tries so hard it blows past the decentralised part and has created essentially a single unified fediverse.

Which sounds beautiful. But it's hard for an instance to have its own culture when every fedi implementation, especially Mastodon, is federation first and foremost. Its goal is to get you and your users connected to the fediverse. In this it excels, mostly, albeit with kinda shoddy mod tools. I just fear the emphasis on this has been at the expense of the ability to have any kind of significantly large subculture on an instance.

It doesn't mean the fediverse isn't good, mind, it just sort of feels like a centralised system still. I know that's the point, but, I dislike that.

fedi meta 

What we basically have on fedi is Twitter except with even more chaotic ad-hoc moderation that varies from instance to instance. If the only point of running an instance is to make your own rules, because you sure as hell can't maintain a thriving community very easily because that is not what Mastodon is for... what's the point?

Show thread

fedi meta 

I know some instances do have some of their own culture but they tend to be the smaller ones. Otherwise it's mostly just the same shit with a different moderator policy.

Show thread

re: fedi meta 

@Elizafox I wish not-mastodon existed

fedi meta 

@Elizafox I wonder if this is part of why we didn't gel with

– Frost

re: fedi meta & reddit 


This is the best aspect of reddit. Although there is an overall reddit culture, each subreddit can, if the community & mods desire, have a distinctive culture that is disconnected from wider reddit culture.
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Interlinked MST3K

this is mst3k